Cooperatives

​

Cooperative Operations Audit Case Example

Context

Cooperative operations can include a wide range of activities, depending on the cooperative’s focus, such as agricultural production, supply procurement, credit unions, or housing. Financial transactions within cooperatives often involve member equity contributions, allocations of surplus to members, and transactions under mutual principles. Accurately accounting for these transactions is essential for presenting the cooperative’s financial position and performance.

Audit Objective

To obtain reasonable assurance that cooperative operations are accurately reflected in the financial statements, including the recognition of member contributions, allocation of surplus, and transactions in accordance with cooperative principles, in compliance with the applicable financial reporting framework.

Types of Audit Evidence and Documentation for Cooperative Operations Assertions

1. Existence

• Case: Verify the existence of assets, liabilities, and equity related to cooperative operations through physical verification, third-party confirmations, or inspection of relevant documentation.

• Documentation: Document the methods and findings from verifying the existence of inventory, fixed assets, member equity accounts, and other significant items.

2. Rights and Obligations

• Case: Confirm the cooperative’s rights to its assets and obligations for its liabilities, including obligations to members.

• Documentation: Summarize the review of legal documents, contracts, and cooperative bylaws that establish the cooperative’s rights and obligations.

3. Completeness

• Case: Ensure that all transactions related to cooperative operations are recorded in the financial statements.

• Documentation: Outline procedures for testing the completeness of transactions, such as reconciling transactions recorded in the accounting system with member contributions, sales records, and payment documentation.

4. Accuracy

• Case: Assess the accuracy of transactions recorded, including member equity contributions, sales, expenses, and allocations of surplus.

• Documentation: Document specific testing procedures and recalculations performed to verify the accuracy of accounting records, highlighting any discrepancies and corrective actions taken.

5. Valuation and Allocation

• Case: Evaluate the appropriate valuation of assets and liabilities and the allocation of surplus to members or reserves.

• Documentation: Document the assessment of valuation methods for assets and liabilities and the basis for surplus allocations, including compliance with cooperative bylaws and financial reporting standards.

6. Presentation and Disclosure

• Case: Review the financial statements to ensure that cooperative operations are correctly classified, described, and disclosed, including member equity, allocations of surplus, and adherence to cooperative principles.

• Documentation: Evaluate the presentation and disclosure of information related to cooperative operations, verifying that it complies with financial reporting standards and provides clear information on the cooperative’s structure, member equity, and surplus allocations.

Additional Considerations

• Member Equity Accounts: Document the examination of the accounting for member contributions, redemptions, and the maintenance of individual member equity accounts.

• Patronage Dividends and Allocations: Assess and document the calculation and distribution of patronage dividends or surplus allocations to members, ensuring the process aligns with cooperative policies and financial reporting standards.

• Tax Implications: Consider the cooperative’s compliance with tax regulations affecting cooperatives, including the treatment of patronage dividends and member contributions, documenting the cooperative’s adherence to tax laws.

• Internal Controls Evaluation: Evaluate the design and effectiveness of internal controls over the recording and reporting of transactions specific to cooperative operations.

• Inquiries of Management and Governance: Conduct inquiries with cooperative management and governance bodies regarding the policies and procedures for managing member equity, surplus allocations, and adherence to cooperative principles.

Conclusion

The audit of cooperative operations is crucial for ensuring that financial statements accurately represent the cooperative’s financial position, performance, and adherence to cooperative principles. Documenting the audit procedures and findings related to each relevant assertion provides a foundation for the auditor’s opinion, enhancing the credibility and transparency of financial reporting related to cooperative activities.​⬤