Accounting Estimates

​

Audit of Management Estimates Case Example: ABC Manufacturing Company

Context

Given the complexity of ABC Manufacturing Company’s operations and the evolving market conditions, management must make several significant estimates affecting the financial statements. These include estimates related to warranty liabilities, asset impairments, and revenue recognition under long-term contracts.

Audit Objective

To evaluate the reasonableness of management’s estimates in the financial statements, ensuring they are based on appropriate assumptions, accounting policies, and data, and to assess whether they are free from bias and misstatement.

Types of Audit Evidence and Documentation for Audit of Management Estimates

1. Understanding How Management Develops Estimates

• Case: Gain an understanding of the process management uses to develop estimates, including the identification of relevant data, selection of assumptions, and determination of the methodological approach.

• Documentation: Document the auditors’ understanding of the process, including any models or data sources used by management and the rationale behind chosen assumptions.

2. Evaluating the Reasonableness of Assumptions and Methods

• Case: Assess whether the assumptions and methods used by management are reasonable, considering historical accuracy, industry standards, and external data.

• Documentation: Prepare an analysis of the assumptions and methods, noting any areas of concern or deviations from expected practices. Document discussions with management regarding the basis for assumptions and methods.

3. Testing the Data Used by Management

• Case: Verify the accuracy and completeness of the data used by management in making estimates. This may involve agreeing data to source documents or evaluating the reliability of external information.

• Documentation: Summarize the testing performed on the data used in estimates, including any discrepancies found and how they were resolved.

4. Independent Recalculation of Estimates

• Case: Where practical, independently recalculate estimates to compare with management’s figures. This can involve using different models, assumptions, or data to assess the range of reasonable estimates.

• Documentation: Document the independent recalculations, including any differences from management’s estimates and the implications for the audit.

5. Evaluating the Disclosure of Estimates

• Case: Review the financial statement disclosures related to significant estimates to ensure they are complete, accurate, and provide users with sufficient information about the uncertainties and risks associated with the estimates.

• Documentation: Document the evaluation of disclosures, noting whether they appropriately reflect the uncertainties and judgments involved in making the estimates.

6. Assessing the Potential for Management Bias

• Case: Consider whether there is evidence of management bias in the selection of assumptions, methods, or adjustments made to estimates, and evaluate the implications for the financial statements.

• Documentation: Summarize any findings of potential management bias, including the nature of the bias, its impact on the estimates, and any discussions with management regarding these concerns.

7. Concluding on the Reasonableness of Estimates

• Case: Based on the audit procedures performed, conclude on the overall reasonableness of management’s estimates and whether they are appropriately reflected in the financial statements.

• Documentation: Prepare a conclusion memo that outlines the auditor’s assessment of the reasonableness of management’s estimates, including any adjustments proposed, adjustments made, or additional disclosures recommended.

Conclusion

The audit of management estimates is a critical aspect of the audit process, requiring auditors to exercise professional judgment and skepticism. Through a thorough documentation process, auditors provide evidence of their assessment of the reasonableness of management’s estimates and the appropriateness of the related financial statement disclosures. This ensures that the financial statements provide a fair representation of the company’s financial position and performance, considering the inherent uncertainty in management estimates.