Revenue

​

Revenue Audit Case Example: ABC Manufacturing Company

Context

ABC Manufacturing Company generates revenue from the sale of electronic components across various markets. Given the complexity of revenue recognition, especially considering contracts, discounts, returns, and warranties, auditing revenue involves a detailed approach tailored to the company’s specific revenue streams and practices.

Audit Objective

To obtain reasonable assurance that revenue transactions recorded in ABC Manufacturing Company’s financial statements are complete, accurate, occur at the correct time, are properly classified, and occur from genuine transactions.

Types of Audit Evidence and Documentation for Revenue Assertions

1. Occurrence

• Case: Verify that revenue recognized in the period actually occurred and pertains to genuine sales transactions.

• Documentation: Document tests of details performed on a sample of sales transactions, tracing them from the financial statements to supporting documentation such as contracts, shipping documents, and customer orders.

2. Completeness

• Case: Ensure that all revenue transactions that should have been recorded are indeed reflected in the financial statements.

• Documentation: Summarize the procedures for testing the completeness of revenue, such as matching shipping documents to sales records and tracing to recorded revenue, and reconciliation of sales ledger to the general ledger.

3. Accuracy

• Case: Confirm that revenue transactions are recorded at the correct amounts and terms reflected in the underlying agreements.

• Documentation: Document the examination of selected sales transactions, comparing contract terms, invoice amounts, and accounting records to ensure accuracy in revenue recognition.

4. Cutoff

• Case: Assess whether revenue transactions are recorded in the correct accounting period, especially around the year-end.

• Documentation: Outline the procedures for testing the sales cutoff, including reviewing sales transactions before and after year-end for proper recording based on shipping dates or service completion.

5. Classification

• Case: Evaluate whether revenue transactions are classified correctly according to the applicable financial reporting framework and the company’s specific revenue categories.

• Documentation: Summarize the review of revenue classifications in the financial statements, including testing a sample of transactions to ensure they are categorized correctly.

6. Assessment of Revenue Recognition Policies

• Case: Review and assess ABC Manufacturing Company’s revenue recognition policies for compliance with the applicable financial reporting standards (e.g., IFRS 15, ASC 606).

• Documentation: Document the assessment of the company’s revenue recognition policies, including any areas of judgment or estimation in revenue recognition and the appropriateness of the policies applied.

7. Evaluation of Internal Controls over Revenue

• Case: Evaluate the design and implementation of internal controls over revenue recognition, including controls over the approval of significant contracts, the accuracy of invoicing, and the recording of revenue transactions.

• Documentation: Document the evaluation of internal controls over revenue, noting the control environment, any control activities tested, and the effectiveness of these controls.

8. Communication with Management and Those Charged with Governance

• Case: Discuss significant findings from the revenue audit with management and those charged with governance, particularly any issues related to revenue recognition, cutoff practices, or the need for adjustments.

• Documentation: Prepare a summary of communications regarding revenue recognition issues, including management’s responses and any agreed-upon adjustments or disclosures.

Conclusion

Auditing revenue with consideration of all relevant assertions is crucial for providing reasonable assurance that the revenue recognized in ABC Manufacturing Company’s financial statements is fairly presented. Documenting the audit procedures and findings related to each revenue assertion supports the auditor’s opinion on the financial statements and helps stakeholders understand the basis for the auditor’s conclusions regarding revenue recognition.