AWP 6

​

Rights and Ownership Case Example: Intellectual Property Rights (IPR)

Context

ABC Manufacturing Company holds patents and trademarks critical to its operations in the electronic components industry. These IPRs contribute significantly to the company’s competitive advantage and valuation. Verifying the company’s legal rights to these assets ensures they are rightfully owned and properly reflected in the financial statements.

Audit Objective

To confirm that ABC Manufacturing Company legally owns or has rights to use the intellectual property reflected in its financial statements and that these rights are accurately valued and recorded.

Types of Audit Evidence and Documentation for Rights and Ownership

1. Review of Legal Documents

• Case: Auditors examine patents, trademarks registrations, licensing agreements, and any litigation documents related to IPR.

• Documentation: Documentation includes a list of IPRs reviewed, summaries of key terms, expiration dates, and any restrictions or obligations. Legal opinions or correspondence confirming rights may also be included.

2. Inquiries of Management and Legal Counsel

• Case: Conduct discussions with management and, if applicable, the company’s legal counsel to understand the process of managing IPR and any issues related to rights or disputes.

• Documentation: Summarize the discussions, highlighting management’s assertion of ownership or rights and any relevant legal counsel opinions or representations.

3. Verification of Registration

• Case: Verify the current status of patents and trademarks by checking public registers or databases.

• Documentation: Document the verification process, including dates of registration, renewal statuses, and any findings related to the legal standing of the IPR.

4. Assessment of Valuation and Amortization

• Case: For intangible assets like IPR, assess the methodologies used for valuation and amortization, ensuring they’re in line with accounting standards and reflect the asset’s economic benefit period.

• Documentation: Include analyses of valuation models, useful life assessments, and amortization schedules. Discrepancies or adjustments should be documented, including rationale and impact on financial statements.

5. Impairment Testing

• Case: If there are indicators of impairment (e.g., legal disputes, market changes affecting the IPR value), perform or review impairment tests.

• Documentation: Detail the impairment testing process, assumptions, calculations, and conclusions. If impairment is identified, document the discussions with management regarding recognition and measurement.

6. Management Representations

• Case: Obtain management’s written representations that all significant IPRs are fully owned or legally utilized under agreement, and that rights and obligations are appropriately reflected in the financial statements.

• Documentation: Include the representation letter or specific sections related to IPR, highlighting management’s assertion of rights and ownership and any guarantees of title.

Conclusion

For rights and ownership, particularly concerning intellectual property rights, auditors gather and document a comprehensive set of evidence. This evidence serves to verify that ABC Manufacturing Company legally owns or has the right to use the intellectual property assets reported in its financial statements, ensuring that these assets and any related liabilities or restrictions are accurately reflected and valued. This meticulous documentation supports the auditors’ opinion on the financial statements, providing confidence to stakeholders about the integrity of reported asset ownership and rights.